Rigorous Benchmarking in Reasonable Time

TitleRigorous Benchmarking in Reasonable Time
Publication TypeConference Paper
Year of Publication2013
AuthorsKalibera, T, Jones R
Conference NameProceedings of the 2013 International Symposium on Memory Management
Date Published06/2013
PublisherACM
Conference LocationNew York, NY, USA
ISBN Number978-1-4503-2100-6
Keywordsbenchmarking methodology, DaCapo, spec cpu, statistical methods
Abstract

Experimental evaluation is key to systems research. Because modern systems are complex and non-deterministic, good experimental methodology demands that researchers account for uncertainty. To obtain valid results, they are expected to run many iterations of benchmarks, invoke virtual machines (VMs) several times, or even rebuild VM or benchmark binaries more than once. All this repetition costs time to complete experiments. Currently, many evaluations give up on sufficient repetition or rigorous statistical methods, or even run benchmarks only in training sizes. The results reported often lack proper variation estimates and, when a small difference between two systems is reported, some are simply unreliable.

In contrast, we provide a statistically rigorous methodology for repetition and summarising results that makes efficient use of experimentation time. Time efficiency comes from two key observations. First, a given benchmark on a given platform is typically prone to much less non-determinism than the common worst-case of published corner-case studies. Second, repetition is most needed where most uncertainty arises (whether between builds, between executions or between iterations). We capture experimentation cost with a novel mathematical model, which we use to identify the number of repetitions at each level of an experiment necessary and sufficient to obtain a given level of precision.

We present our methodology as a cookbook that guides researchers on the number of repetitions they should run to obtain reliable results. We also show how to present results with an effect size confidence interval. As an example, we show how to use our methodology to conduct throughput experiments with the DaCapo and SPEC CPU benchmarks on three recent platforms.

URLhttp://doi.acm.org/10.1145/2464157.2464160
DOI10.1145/2464157.2464160
Refereed DesignationRefereed